Why Employers Use Settlement Agreements in Redundancy Situations

In my role as a settlement agreement solicitor I advise and represent employees in the resolution of claims and disputes with their employer. In a redundancy situation, employers often opt for a settlement agreement, a settlement agreement is a legally binding contract between an employer and an employee, used to terminate the employment relationship on mutually agreed terms. Employers often opt for a settlement agreement for several key reasons.

Reasons Employers Opt for a Settlement Agreement

Certainty and Finality

Firstly, to achieve certainty and finality. Redundancy processes, if not handled meticulously, can lead to claims of unfair dismissal. A settlement agreement provides a clean break, preventing future disputes and potential litigation. By signing the agreement, the employee typically waives their right to bring any claims against the employer related to their employment or its termination, offering the employer peace of mind.

Confidentiality and Reputation

Secondly, to ensure confidentiality and protect reputation. Often, a settlement agreement will include clauses that prevent the employee from disclosing sensitive company information or making derogatory comments about the employer. This is particularly valuable in redundancy situations where an employer wants to manage public perception and protect their brand.

Amicable Seperation

Thirdly, to facilitate a swift and amicable separation. Redundancy can be emotionally charged. A settlement agreement, by offering clear terms and often an enhanced payment, can encourage a more cooperative departure, reducing animosity and the potential for a drawn-out, contentious process.

‍

The Tactic of an Enhanced Termination Payment

‍
A common tactic employed by businesses in redundancy scenarios is to offer an enhanced termination payment – a sum of money that exceeds the statutory redundancy pay an employee would be legally entitled to. This might seem like an act of generosity, but it's often a calculated move.

‍
Statutory redundancy pay is a legal minimum based on an employee's age, length of service, and weekly pay (up to a capped amount). The enhanced payment, however, goes beyond this. Employers use this higher offer as an incentive for the employee to sign the settlement agreement and, crucially, to waive their rights to pursue further claims.

The rationale behind this tactic is multifaceted. From an employer's perspective, paying a higher sum upfront via a settlement agreement can be significantly cheaper and less disruptive than defending an unfair dismissal claim at an employment tribunal. Tribunal proceedings are costly, time-
consuming, and can generate negative publicity. An enhanced payment, therefore, is often a pragmatic business decision to mitigate risk and avoid future liabilities.

‍
The Hidden Truth: Unfair Redundancy and the Need for Legal Advice

While an enhanced payment can appear attractive, it is absolutely essential for an employee to seek independent legal advice from an expert settlement agreement solicitor before signing anything. This is because, on many occasions, the enhanced termination payment is masking an unfair redundancy. An employer might offer an enhanced payment to "buy off" potential claims where the redundancy process itself was flawed or discriminatory. For example, if:

• The selection criteria were unfair or subjective.
• The consultation process was inadequate.
• There was no genuine redundancy situation.
• The redundancy was a pretext for dismissing an employee for another, unlawful reason (e.g., discrimination based on age, gender, or disability).
• The employer failed to consider suitable alternative employment.

‍
In such scenarios, if an employee were aware of the true nature of the redundancy – that it was fundamentally unfair – they could potentially bring a claim for significant compensation before an employment tribunal. An expert settlement agreement solicitor will scrutinise the circumstances of the redundancy, advise on the strength of any potential claims, and determine if the enhanced payment truly reflects the compensation an employee might be entitled to if they pursued a claim.
They can also negotiate a higher settlement figure if the employer's offer is insufficient given the potential risks they face.

‍
Without independent legal advice, an employee might unknowingly sign away their rights for a sum far less than they could legitimately claim, effectively letting the employer off the hook for an unfair dismissal. Therefore, while a settlement agreement can offer a clean break, it's a document that demands careful legal scrutiny to ensure the employee's rights and interests are fully protected.

‍

As an experienced and qualified settlement agreement solicitor, I can help you understand your rights, assess the fairness of any proposed terms, and determine if any improper behaviour has occurred, ensuring you make informed decisions about your future. Get in touch today, call 0330 043 8845, email clive@solicitor.help, or request a call back.